Death has Deep Roots – Michael Gilbert



Victoria Lamartine is on trial for the murder of Major Eric Thoseby. The murder was committed in a small in the Family Hotel in Pearlyman Street, run by Monsieur Sainte, who came to London after the war. Vicky is another French refugee, assisted by the Société de Lorraine, an organisation set up to help French citizens in London, to find work after suffering imprisonment & torture by the Gestapo for her role in the Resistance in the Angers region. Thoseby had been the SOE contact in the area. He knew Vicky & she had been in contact with him after the war, trying to trace Lieutenant Julian Wells, the father of her baby. Vicky gave birth in a prison camp & the baby later died of malnutrition but Vicky didn’t believe the story that Julian had been killed by the Gestapo in the same raid when she was caught. Thoseby was at the hotel that night to meet Vicky & she was discovered standing over his body. The murder weapon, a kitchen knife, has her prints on it & the very efficient method used to stab Thoseby was taught to Resistance fighters during the war.

Nap Rumbold is the junior partner in his father’s firm of solicitors. He is surprised to be contacted by Vicky’s solicitors two days before the trial commences & asked to take on the case. Vicky was dissatisfied with her counsel, who obviously believed her guilty, & she had heard of Nap through Major Thoseby (they were wartime colleagues). Nap agrees to see Vicky & is impressed by her story. The police case is that Major Thoseby was the father of Vicky’s child & that she murdered him when he refused to support her. Nap believes her innocent but realises how difficult it will be to prove her innocence & discover the true murderer. Nap enlists Major Angus McCann, a private investigator, to pursue the London end of the investigation while he goes to France to look into the wartime roots of the relationship between Vicky & Thoseby. The investigation is complicated by the other guests at the hotel, including alcoholic Colonel Alwright & Mrs Gwendolyne Roper, whose evidence seems damning until her own activities are scrutinised.

This is a great combination of courtroom drama & adventure story. The background of the war & the French Resistance is exciting & Nap’s investigations in Angers reveal many secrets that desperate men would kill to keep hidden. The chapters alternate between the trial & Nap’s investigations & this structure works very successfully. I’ve always been a fan of courtroom drama (Witness for the Prosecution is one of my favourite movies) & the sober recounting of evidence contrasts well with the chapters in France as Nap tries to break through the obstructions of people who have many secrets. The wartime background is fascinating as the motives of everyone involved are untangled & the time constraints involved ramp up the tension beautifully. It was a real treat to have the opportunity to read Death has Deep Roots for the 1951 Club.

The 1951 Club has been a wonderful excuse to read & reread some terrific books. There are lots of links to more reviews on Simon’s blog here. As well as the two books I’ve reviewed, I’ve also listened to the audio book of The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey, read by Derek Jacobi. This is one of my favourite books & I must have read or listened to it over 20 times. I’ve also reviewed My Cousin Rachel by Daphne Du Maurier (I’m looking forward to the new movie very much. There’s a trailer here). Other reviews on the blog – The Blessing by Nancy Mitford, Round the Bend by Nevil Shute, There are so many more that I read pre-blog, 1951 must be one of my favourite reading years! One that brought back happy memories when I saw it in the Goodreads list was Désirée by Annemarie Selinko, a romantic novel about Napoleon’s first love. I’ve also read The End of the Affair by Graham Green, They Came to Baghdad by Agatha Christie, The Day of the Triffids by John Wyndham (after seeing the TV series with John Duttine back in the 70s), Ellen Tebbits by Beverly Cleary (a childhood favourite), Night at the Vulcan by Ngaio Marsh, Duplicate Death by Georgette Heyer, A Game of Hide and Seek by Elizabeth Taylor, An English Murder by Cyril Hare, The Lute Player by Norah Lofts & Florence Nightingale by Cecil Woodham-Smith. I’d recommend them all, even though I read many of them over 35 years ago. What a great year for publishing!

13 thoughts on “Death has Deep Roots – Michael Gilbert

  1. Michael Gilbert has a number of good mysteries to his credit: very enjoyable reading… Anthony Gilbert is also good… i don’t know if the two are related or not…


    • AG was the pen name of Lucy Malleson so no relation. MG’s daughter, Harriett, presents the BBC Radio book programs A Good Read & World Book Club which I really enjoy. You can download them as podcasts as well. I’ve read a few MGs but want to read more. I have a couple tbr.


  2. I’ve read almost all the books you’ve mentioned, Lyn. Wow – who knew that 1951 was such a rich year for books and reading? I am a major Golden Age fan so this sounds like a great reading club. 🙂 I’ve just recently discovered the books of Michael Gilbert and read a few (one of which I reviewed on my blog) but I haven’t read the one you’re reviewing so that gives me an excuse (if I needed one) to find another Gilbert mystery.

    I love audio books and I love THE DAUGHTER OF TIME, it’s one of my very favorite books. Certainly, Josephine Tey’s masterpiece. But I’ve never heard the audio version. Derek Jacobi? I will definitely have to get it.


    • I got the audio of DOT through Audible & it was very cheap using Whispersync. DJ does a great job. I’ve listened to it many times, even on cassette in the olden days! I was so pleased that it was still available through Audible. I wish some of my other old favourites still were. Michael Gilbert is very good & he wrote a lot so I hope to read more of his books soon.


  3. I’m ashamed to say that I hadn’t heard of Michael Gilbert before so I will keep an eye out for him in future. I’m very late to the 1951 party. I was very slow reading the books and thinking about them but I really enjoyed this exercise.


    • MG had a very long career but hasn’t received the acclaim of other Golden Age writers. Maybe because he didn’t have a long-running series character. I’ve only read a few of his books but enjoyed them all. The Clubs are a lot of fun & a good reason to look through the tbr shelves for suitable titles which is always a good thing. It’s the only challenge I take part in but I always enjoy reading for it & seeing what other people are reading as well.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s